7 Chicken Salad Copycats Compared: Recipes to Make This Week

By Stephanie Manley Updated 11/20/26

Chicken Salad Copycats Compared brings together eight of my copycat chicken salad recipes from restaurant chains like Chicken Salad Chick, Arby’s, Jason’s Deli, and Newk’s. You’ll find classic, fruity, nutty, dill, and barbecue versions, plus a broccoli salad side. Each one uses easy-to-find ingredients, so you can choose the right one for your next lunch or gathering.

Add this site as a preferred Google source!

Chicken salad is one of those lunches I never get tired of, and every restaurant seems to have its own version. Over the past few years, I’ve worked through a whole stack of them, from the Classic Carol at Chicken Salad Chick to the pecan chicken salad sandwich at Arby’s. Some are sweet with grapes and apples, some are tangy with dill, and one is a barbecue twist I didn’t expect to love.

Right now feels like the perfect time to bring them together. Spring lunches, graduation parties, and cookouts all call for something you can make ahead and keep in the fridge. Most take 10 to 30 minutes, and nearly all use ingredients you can find at any grocery store.

I’ve put them side by side here so you can see how each one differs. Read through the list, find the flavor that sounds like your kind of lunch, and start with that one. You may find you want to make several of them before the week is out.

1. Chicken Salad Chick Classic Carol Chicken Salad

Sandwiches made with copycat Chicken Salad Chick Classic Carol chicken salad.

Start with the one that started it all. My Classic Carol copycat uses chicken tenderloins poached in low-sodium chicken stock, then dressed with Duke’s mayo, celery, and a bit of dry ranch mix. The tenderloins give the shreds the same texture I remember from the restaurant, so make this version if you want the original taste.

Get the Recipe

2. Chicken Salad Chick Fancy Nancy Easy Copycat Recipe

chicken salad with grapes, apples, and pecans on top of lettuce on a plate

Fancy Nancy is my pick for anyone who likes sweet and crunchy together. Shredded chicken is mixed with crisp Fuji apples, red grapes, pecans, and finely minced celery in a mayo and ranch dressing. Make it a couple of hours ahead so the flavors can come together.

Get the Recipe

3. Arby’s Pecan Chicken Salad Sandwich Recipe: Elevate Your Lunch Game

Copycat Arby

This one is for anyone who misses Arby’s pecan chicken salad when it’s off the menu. I layer cooked chicken with red apple, halved red grapes, pecans, and celery in a lemon-brightened mayo dressing. It works on toasted sourdough or honey wheat, in a wrap, or over greens, and comes together in about 20 minutes.

Get the Recipe

4. Jason’s Deli Chicken Salad Recipe (Easy 6-Ingredient Copycat)

Copycat Jason

Jason’s Deli chicken salad has the shortest ingredient list in this roundup. You’ll mix cooked chicken breast with mayo, crushed pineapple, sliced almonds, salt, and black pepper. It’s ready in about 10 minutes, so it’s my go-to when I need lunch in a hurry.

Get the Recipe

5. Chicken Salad Chick Dill-icious Diva Recipe – Copycat Version

Copycat chicken salad chick dill-icious chicken salad on lettuce leaves.

Dill-icious Diva is the one I make when I’m craving something fresh and light. Poach the tenders in water with Knorr chicken bouillon, then toss with fresh dill, crisp cucumber, Duke’s mayo, and a little dry ranch mix. It’s a seasonal favorite at the restaurant, and this version lets you enjoy it year-round.

Get the Recipe

6. Chicken Salad Chick Barbie-Q – Easy Copycat Recipe

Copycat chicken salad chick barbie q chicken salad sandwich.

Barbie-Q brings barbecue right into the chicken salad bowl. Chicken tenderloins poached in low-sodium stock are mixed with mayo, your favorite barbecue sauce, dry ranch mix, salt, and pepper. Choose a sweeter or smokier sauce to tune the heat and tang, and serve it on sandwiches, crackers, or salads.

Get the Recipe

7. Copycat Newk’s Chicken Salad Recipe

chicken salad sandwich on a plate

Newk’s chicken salad is perfect for a make-ahead lunch for the whole week. Pound the chicken thin, sear it in a sauté pan, then chill it before mixing with red grapes, pecans, celery, red onion, lemon juice, and mayo. Let it rest in the fridge so the flavors meld.

Get the Recipe

Pick one of these eight and make it this week, then come back and tell me which one won your family over. I’d love to hear whether you liked the sweet fruit versions or the tangy ones better. Happy cooking.

More Ideas

REVEALED Olive Garden Copycat Recipes

yes, you CAN make it at home! I’ll show you how.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *