Nostalgic School Cafeteria Pizza Burgers: Easy Family Dinner Recipe

The first time I bit into a pizza burger in my elementary school cafeteria, I knew this wasn’t just another lunch. That magical combination of savory meat sauce, melted cheese, and toasted bread transported me to flavor paradise. Every Friday, I’d hope to see these on the menu. Now as an adult, I’ve perfected my version that brings back those childhood memories while being substantial enough for a family dinner. The best part? My kids love customizing their own just as much as I loved eating them back then!

What Makes Pizza Burgers Special?

• The recipe easily scales up for large gatherings or down for a small family meal
• They combine two beloved American classics: pizza and burgers into one irresistible meal
• They’re incredibly versatile and perfect for customization by each family member
• Unlike traditional burgers, these open-faced sandwiches pack all the flavor of pizza
• They’re quick to prepare and perfect for busy weeknights when you need dinner fast

Tips for Making Eating Pizza Burgers

• Let everyone choose their own toppings. Get your kids involved with making this recipe by helping them come up with their own flavor combinations.
• Make a double batch of meat mixture and put it in the fridge for a quick meal. Make this up to two days before using or freeze for up to a month.
• Use a knife and fork. There is no shame in being slightly civilized.

See what else we are cooking up on Facebook!

Pizza Burgers Recipe Ingredients

Here’s a list of what you need:

• Italian Sausage – Provides rich, aromatic flavor with notes of fennel and herbs that give these burgers their distinctive pizza-like taste
• Ground Beef – Creates the hearty base and traditional burger texture while balancing the stronger flavors of the Italian sausage
• Tomato Sauce – Acts as the binding agent for the meat mixture while delivering classic pizza sauce flavor and moisture
• Canned Sliced Mushrooms – Adds an earthy umami flavor and meaty texture that complements the beef and sausage
• Dried Oregano – Contributes the quintessential Italian herb flavor that makes these taste authentically like pizza
• Garlic Salt – Infuses the meat mixture with garlicky flavor and proper seasoning in one convenient ingredient
• Shredded Mozzarella Cheese – Creates that perfect melty, stretchy pizza-like cheese pull while adding creamy richness
• Hamburger Buns – Serve as the pizza “crust” foundation, providing structure and a slightly sweet complement to the savory topping

How to Make Pizza Burgers

1. Brown the sausage and ground beef in a pan over medium-high heat.
2. Drain and return meat to the pan or place it in a bowl.
3. Add tomato sauce, mushrooms, oregano, and garlic salt. Stir until well combined.
   

   

4. Place the top and bottom buns inside up on a baking sheet.
5. Spoon the meat mixture onto the buns.
6. Sprinkle cheese on top.
   

   

7. Bake until the cheese is melted and bubbly.

The Perfect Pizza Burger Base Options

Pizza burgers are traditionally made with hamburger buns, but you have several options for your “crust”:

• Kaiser or Hoagie Rolls – More substantial than burger buns and less likely to get soggy
• English Muffins – Provide a sturdy base with nooks and crannies that catch the sauce beautifully
• Thick Sliced Sourdough – Offers a tangy flavor that complements the savory meat mixture
• Sweet Hawaiian Rolls – Create an interesting sweet-savory contrast (be sure to toast them first)
• Garlic Bread – For an extra flavor boost that complements the Italian ingredients

Creative Topping Combinations

Beyond the basic recipe, try these tasty variations:

• Classic Pepperoni – Add sliced pepperoni under the cheese before baking
• Veggie Supreme – Top with diced bell peppers, onions, and olives
• Balsamic Caramelized Onion & Gruyere – Substitute Gruyere cheese and add pre-cooked caramelized onions
• Mac & Cheese – Spread a layer of prepared mac and cheese over the meat for a kid-friendly option
• Spicy Jalapeño – Add sliced jalapeños and substitute cheddar cheese for a kick

Storage and Reheating Instructions

• Refrigeration – Store leftover meat mixture separately from buns in airtight containers for up to 3 days
• Freezing – The meat mixture freezes well for up to 1 month in freezer-safe containers
• Reheating – Warm meat mixture in a microwave or on stovetop before assembling fresh pizza burgers

Why Make Pizza Burgers?

These nostalgic open-faced sandwiches aren’t just delicious—they’re the perfect solution for busy families. They come together quickly, can be customized to please everyone’s taste preferences, and combine two favorite foods in one satisfying meal. Plus, they’re budget-friendly and utilize ingredients you likely already have in your pantry!

This family-friendly dinner is sure to become a regular in your meal rotation. The combination of savory meat, zesty sauce, and melty cheese on toasted buns delivers all the comfort food satisfaction you’re craving without the hassle of making pizza dough or shaping burger patties.

Love burgers? Try these recipes!

• Backyard Burger
• Culver’s Burgers
• Garlic Burger
• Juicy Lucy
• Old Fashioned Hamburgers
• Pimento Cheese Burger
• Vegan Burger
• White Castle Burger
• Whopper

Favorite Sandwich Recipes

• Chick-fil-A Chicken Sandwich
• Chicken Fried Steak Sandwich
• Monte Cristo Sandwich

Check out my easy burger recipes and family favorite recipes here on CopyKat!

The recipe comes from Sue A. Mertens Minick from Hazelwood, MO. She actually found this site on the internet! Turns out she is family of mine.