Fatburger Banana Milkshake (Thick & Creamy Copycat Recipe)

When the summer heat hits or you’re craving something indulgently sweet, nothing beats the legendary thick and creamy texture of a Fatburger Banana Milkshake. This copycat recipe captures all the rich, velvety goodness of the original using a clever combination of vanilla ice cream, half-and-half, and instant banana pudding mix that creates an impossibly thick consistency you can’t get with regular milk.

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Why This Recipe Works

The genius lies in combining textures and the strategic use of instant pudding mix. While regular banana milkshakes can be thin and lack intense flavor, this recipe creates restaurant-quality thickness and a concentrated banana taste. The half-and-half provides richness without making the shake too heavy, while the pudding mix acts as both a flavoring and a thickening agent.

Ingredients

Base Components:

• Premium vanilla ice cream – Forms the creamy foundation and provides rich dairy flavor without competing with the banana taste
• Half-and-half – Creates the perfect consistency between heavy cream and milk for optimal blending and richness
• Instant banana pudding mix – Delivers concentrated banana flavor and creates a signature thick texture that defines this shake

Optional Enhancements:

• Fresh banana – Adds natural banana flavor and extra creaminess when blended, plus makes beautiful garnish when sliced
• Whipped cream – Provides classic milkshake topping and additional indulgent texture contrast

How to Make Banana Milkshake

1. Place ice cream in a blender.
   

   

2. Add half and half.
   

   

3. Add banana pudding mix.
   

   

4. Blend until smooth and creamy.
5. Pour the milkshake into a glass.
   

   

6. Top with whipped cream if desired.

Tips for Serving a Fatburger Banana Shake

• Use a thick straw. This stuff is thick, and an ordinary straw isn’t going to work. For the best results, try using straws designed for drinking boba tea.
• Don’t forget the whipped cream and toppings. In addition to banana slices, why not add crushed walnuts, chocolate chips, or both?

See what we are up to on Facebook!

Love milkshakes and frozen drinks? Try these recipes!

• Caramel Frappuccino
• Chick-fil-A Peach Milkshake
• Frosted Lemonade Recipe
• Orange Julius Smoothie
• Pina Colada Smoothie
• S’mores Frappuccino
• Shamrock Shake Recipe
• Strawberry and Cream Frappuccino
• Strawberry Banana Smoothie
• Vanilla Frappuccino

Favorite Fast Food Ice Cream Treats

• Chips Ahoy McFlurry
• Dairy Queen Oreo Blizzard
• Oreo McFlurry
• Wendy’s Frosty

Check out my easy drink recipes and the best fast food recipes here on CopyKat!