Discover the magic of New Orleans’ most beloved cocktail with this authentic milk punch recipe that transforms simple ingredients into liquid comfort. This creamy, boozy milkshake combines vanilla ice cream with a perfect blend of bourbon, rum, and brandy, creating a sophisticated adult beverage synonymous with Southern hospitality. Whether you’re hosting holiday parties or want to experience a taste of the Big Easy at home, this versatile cocktail delivers the perfect balance of indulgence and refreshment that has made it a staple in New Orleans bars for generations.
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Table of Contents
Why This Recipe Works
The genius of milk punch lies in its perfect balance of creamy sweetness and warming spirits. The vanilla ice cream provides rich texture and sweetness while tempering the alcohol’s heat, creating a smooth, drinkable cocktail that’s surprisingly refreshing. Combining three different spirits adds complexity without overwhelming the palate, while the nutmeg garnish provides aromatic warmth that enhances every sip.
What is Milk Punch?
Milk Punch is a classic New Orleans cocktail that’s essentially an elegant adult milkshake. Traditionally served during holiday celebrations and special brunches throughout the South, this creamy libation combines dairy with spirits and warming spices. While variations exist across different regions, the New Orleans version stands out for its use of multiple spirits and ice cream, creating a dessert-like consistency that’s both indulgent and surprisingly refreshing.
Ingredients
- Vanilla ice cream – Creates the signature creamy base and provides natural sweetness
- Milk – Adds smooth liquid consistency and balances the richness
- Bourbon – Provides warm, caramel-like depth as the primary spirit
- Light rum – Adds tropical sweetness and complexity
- Brandy – Contributes sophisticated fruit notes and aromatic depth
- Ground nutmeg – Traditional garnish that adds a warming spice aroma
How to Make Milk Punch
- Place the ice cream in a container.
- Add milk, bourbon, rum, and brandy.
- Stir to combine, just enough to have a milkshake consistency.
- Serve in punch cups or lowball glasses.
- Sprinkle a dash of nutmeg on top.
- Garnish with a cinnamon stick if desired.
Chef’s Notes
The key to perfect milk punch is finding the right consistency. You want it creamy enough to coat the glass but liquid enough to drink easily. Start with less milk and add more as needed to achieve your preferred texture. Serve immediately for the best experience, as the ice cream will continue to melt.
Recipe Variations & Customizations
- Richness Levels: Substitute half-and-half for milk to create an even more decadent version, or use whole milk for standard richness
- Flavor Variations: Try different ice cream flavors like cinnamon, butter pecan, or even peppermint for holiday versions
- Spirit Adjustments: Increase bourbon for whiskey lovers, add more rum for tropical notes, or emphasize brandy for fruit-forward flavor
- Spice Options: Experiment with cinnamon, cloves, or pumpkin pie spice for different seasonal profiles
- Alcohol-Free Version: Omit spirits and add vanilla extract, almond extract, or rum flavoring for a family-friendly treat
- Single Spirit Version: Use only bourbon for a simpler, more focused flavor profile
Storage & Timing Instructions
- Make-Ahead: Prepare individual portions as needed rather than large batches to maintain quality and texture.
- Immediate Consumption: This cocktail is best enjoyed within 30 minutes of preparation while maintaining its milkshake-like consistency.
- Refrigeration: This is not recommended for storage as ice cream will separate and the texture will suffer significantly.
Love homemade cocktails? Try these recipes!
- B52 Shot Recipe
- Fish Bowl Drink
- Fuzzy Navel
- Godfather Drink
- Mountain Dew Cocktail
- Mudslide Recipe
- Spiked Eggnog
- White Russian Drink
Favorite Christmas Recipes
Check out my easy cocktail recipes and the best Christmas dinner recipes here on CopyKat!
New Orleans Milk Punch with Bourbon and Rum
Ingredients
- 2 cups vanilla ice cream
- 1 cup milk
- 1/2 cup bourbon
- 1/4 cup light rum
- 3 tablespoons brandy
- ground nutmeg to garnish
- cinnamon sticks to garnish
Instructions
- Place the ice cream in a container and add the milk, bourbon, rum, and brandy. Stir to combine until you achieve a milkshake consistency.
- Serve in punch cups or lowball glasses and garnish with a dash of nutmeg and a cinnamon stick if desired.
I will save this one for the Christmas Holidays! It sound lovely!