Red Lobster Mai Tai Recipe

The first time I served these Red Lobster-inspired Mai Tais at my backyard luau, my neighbor Joe—who considers himself quite the cocktail critic, raised his eyebrows skeptically. “Chain restaurant cocktails?” he questioned with a smirk. Three sips later, he asked for the recipe and planned his tiki party!

This vibrant, fruity Mai Tai perfectly balances white and dark rum with sweet tropical juices for a refreshing escape in a glass. Dating back to the 1940s Polynesian craze that swept America, the Mai Tai remains beloved. While purists might debate ingredients, there’s no arguing with the delicious results of this accessible recipe. Ready in just 5 minutes with easy-to-find ingredients, this cocktail turns any gathering into an instant tropical getaway, with no plane ticket required.

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Why This Recipe Works

The layering technique creates a visually stunning drink while allowing each flavor to shine. The combination of white rum in the base with dark rum floated on top provides complexity that balances perfectly with the sweet-tart fruit juices. Unlike many modern simplified versions, this recipe stays true to the spirit of classic tiki cocktails while remaining accessible for home bartenders.

Mixing Up a Perfect Mai Tai Cocktail

Mai Tais need a good shake to blend correctly. Fill a cocktail shaker with fresh ice and all the Mai Tai ingredients except the Bacardi Dark rum. Hold the shaker with one hand on the bottom and the other on top and shake horizontally for about 10 seconds. Strain the drink into a hurricane glass and garnish with a maraschino cherry and a pineapple spear.

Ingredients

Wondering what is in a Mai Tai? Here’s a list of what you need:

• White rum – Forms the base spirit that blends seamlessly with the fruit juices
• Dark rum – Floated on top to create visual appeal and add rich molasses notes
• Triple sec – Provides orange flavor and balances the sweetness of the fruit juices
• Grenadine – Adds beautiful color and subtle pomegranate sweetness
• Lime juice – Delivers essential acidity that balances the sweet components
• Pineapple juice – Contributes tropical sweetness and signature Mai Tai flavor
• Orange juice – Complements the triple sec and adds natural sweetness
• Pineapple wedge – Serves as a traditional garnish that enhances aroma
• Maraschino cherries – Adds visual appeal and a sweet finishing touch

How to Make a Mai Tai

1. Pour white rum into a cocktail shaker.
2. Add triple sec.
3. Add orange juice.
4. Add lime juice.
5. Add pineapple juice.
6. Add grenadine.
7. Shake and pour into a hurricane glass.
8. Add ice.
9. Pour dark rum on top.
10. Garnish with pineapple and cherries.

Tips for Making and Serving a Tiki Rum Mai Tai

• Make a batch in advance for your next party. Everyone loves Mai Tais, so to save time, consider mixing up a dozen or more servings in a clean milk jug and keeping it in the fridge. When someone wants a Mai Tai, shake the jug, pour the drink, and float the dark rum on top.
• Go crazy with the garnishes. The Tiki culture was known for going overboard on just about everything. Few free to go wild by adding a wooden parasol or an edible tropical flower to the glass to really impress your guests.

Check out more of our Tiki cocktails on YouTube!

Popular Cocktail Recipes

• Corona Margarita
• Godfather Cocktail
• Italian Margarita
• Mountain Dew Margarita
• Mudslide Drink
• Presidente Margarita
• Washington Apple Drink

Favorite Red Lobster Copycat Recipes

• Bacon Wrapped Scallops
• Cheddar Bay Biscuits
• Clam Chowder
• Crab Alfredo
• Scallops Wrapped in Bacon
• Seafood Nachos

Check out my easy cocktail recipes and the best Red Lobster recipes here on CopyKat.