Best Southern Macaroni Salad Recipe (Easy Homemade Side Dish)

Forget everything you know about bland, store-bought macaroni salad. This Southern-style version transforms the humble pasta side dish into something extraordinary with its perfect balance of tangy mustard, sweet vinegar, and creamy mayonnaise dressing.

What sets this recipe apart is the addition of sharp cheddar cheese, colorful vegetables, and a zingy dressing with more personality than your grandmother’s version. Whether you’re heading to a potluck, barbecue, or family gathering, this homemade macaroni salad will be the first dish to disappear from the table.

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Why This Recipe Works

The secret to exceptional macaroni salad lies in the details. Slightly overcooking the pasta ensures it stays tender even when chilled, while the tangy dressing combines mayonnaise with mustard and vinegar for complexity that cuts through the richness. The starch that clings to the pasta acts as a binding agent, helping the dressing coat every piece perfectly. Allowing the salad to rest overnight lets all the flavors meld together, transforming simple ingredients into a cohesive, flavorful side dish that’s far superior to any store-bought version.

Ingredients

For the Pasta Base:

• Elbow macaroni – Traditional pasta shape that holds dressing perfectly in every curve
• Salt – Essential for properly seasoning the pasta cooking water

For the Tangy Dressing:

• Mayonnaise – Creates the creamy base that binds all ingredients together
• White vinegar – Adds bright acidity that balances the rich mayonnaise
• Yellow mustard – Provides tangy flavor and helps emulsify the dressing
• Sugar – Balances the acidity and rounds out the flavors

For the Vegetable Mix:

• Sharp cheddar cheese – Adds richness and sharp flavor that complements the tangy dressing
• Diced pimento peppers – Contributes mild pepper flavor and beautiful red color
• Celery – Provides essential crunch and fresh flavor
• Carrots – Add natural sweetness and vibrant orange color
• Red onion – Delivers sharp bite that cuts through the creamy dressing
• Red bell pepper – Contributes sweet pepper flavor and gorgeous color
• Black pepper – Adds finishing spice that enhances all other flavors

How to Make Macaroni Salad

1. Cook macaroni according to package directions. Drain and allow to cool.
2. Combine mayonnaise, vinegar, sugar, and mustard in a small bowl. Stir until the dressing is well combined.

3. In a large bowl, add cooked macaroni, celery, carrots, onion, bell pepper, pimento peppers, and dressing. Stir to combine.

4. Add shredded cheddar cheese and gently stir to combine.
5. Season with salt and black pepper.
6. Refrigerate the macaroni salad a couple of hours before serving.

Tips for Making and Serving the Best Macaroni Salad

• Always salt the water before boiling the macaroni. A little salt in the pasta’s cooking water is a good thing, but add a bit more salt than you would use when cooking spaghetti for the most flavorsome pasta salad. The reason is simple. Cold dishes dull flavors, and you must amp things up if you want the flavor to come through.
• Slightly overcook the pasta. No, don’t wait until it is mushy to drain; an extra minute of cooking time is actually a good thing when making a cold pasta salad. Cold temperatures make pasta contract, turning perfectly al dente macaroni a little hard. The extra cooking time keeps the pasta soft when it comes out of the fridge.
• Don’t dress the pasta too soon. Let the pasta cool in the strainer before mixing the other ingredients. The starch that clings to the pasta helps bring the pasta salad together, so don’t rinse it off. Speed the cooling by shaking the strainer every once in a while to help redistribute the pasta.
• Make your pasta salad in advance, but not too far in advance. To get the best flavor, let it rest in the fridge for at least four hours, ideally overnight, before eating. Pasta salad can last in the fridge for three or four days.

CopyKat Tip: You can easily make creamy macaroni salad by doubling the dressing and adding a little extra at a time until your desired creaminess is reached.

Storage Instructions

• Freezing: This is not recommended, as mayonnaise-based dressings separate when frozen, and the vegetables lose their crisp texture.
• Refrigerator Storage: Store in airtight containers for up to 4 days. The flavors improve after the first day of chilling.
• Serving Method: Serve chilled directly from the refrigerator.

Favorite Potluck Salads

• Bacon Ranch Pasta Salad Recipe
• Carrot Raisin Salad
• Cold Beet Salad
• Cold Spaghetti Salad
• Copper Penny Carrots
• Ham Salad
• Hot German Potato Salad
• Lime Jello Salad
• Pea Salad with Bacon
• Sweet Tomato Broccoli Salad Recipe

Popular Macaroni and Cheese Recipes

• Boston Market Mac and Cheese
• Instant Pot Macaroni and Cheese
• Martha Stewart Mac and Cheese

Be sure to check out more of my summer salad recipes and the best pasta side dish recipes here on CopyKat!